In 2022, Florida and Texas both passed social media laws that would require online services to carry lawful content, even if it violated the services’ content policies. These laws raise significant First Amendment questions: Is content moderation a form of protected editorial discretion, or a form of “censorship” that the state can prohibit? The lower courts have split on these issues and now the questions are almost certainly headed to the Supreme Court. Join this panel of experts to unpack these cases and understand where they sit in the broader legal doctrine around common carriage, editorial discretion, and the First Amendment.